What Is A Payroll Audit And How Do You Conduct One?

This helps you recognize ghost or phantom employees, which is a type of payroll fraud. The ghost employee may be a terminated employee who has not been taken out of the payroll system or a fictitious employee who does not work for the company. When conducting a payroll audit, you can’t avoid analyzing numbers.

Calibre CPA Group is a full-service accounting and advisory firm with big capabilities. Visit NCCI for more resources and information about workers’ compensation class codes. Visit United States Department of Labor for more information about government agencies managing workers compensation insurance rates. An examination of the insured’s payroll and tax records by a representative of the insurance company. Payroll is the basis of the calculation for each rate and class code.

Risk Of Material Misstatement For Payroll

Auditors can verify commission expense with relative ease if the commission rate is the same for each type of sale and the necessary sales information is available in the accounting records. The total commission expense can be verified by multiplying the commission rate for each type of sale by the amount of sales in that category.

Aside from reviewing what’s in your GL, you should take a look at the specific bank accounts you have set up to manage payroll and payroll tax payments. If you’re using HR or payroll software, check to see if it can create tip reports; they enable you to view employee tip data, amounts, and dates paid. Bonus payouts should be classified as what they are instead of tagging them as regular pay.

• When you hire a third party to perform the audit, you eliminate the risk of an employee concealing payroll data to commit fraud.
• The ultimate goal of an audit is to deliver higher payroll accuracy to your employees and to ensure your payroll processes are fully in compliance with regulations.
• First, the audit period for a payroll audit is not the standard one year period like it is for a financial audit.
• An imprest payroll account is a separate payroll account in which a small balance is maintained.
• Your business should have pay stubs and timesheets for every pay period and every employee.
• Make sure your audit includes a review of payroll taxes so you can identify potential issues, such as incorrect Social Security, federal, or state unemployment tax payments.

Match the pay rates showing in the employee file to the amounts on your payroll reports. If you’re using either an HR software or a payroll system, or both, these solutions typically have reports that list your employees’ names, start dates, and pay rates. You ultimately want to see that no one is getting paid more or less than they should. Conducting a payroll audit is critical in combating these possible issues.

Verify Variable Payments

Master files should be audited each payroll period for changes, errors or discrepancies by a supervisor who does not prepare payroll. Payroll fraud amounts to more than 9 percent of all occupational fraud and abuse cases, according to a 2012 survey by the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners. One of the greatest hazards in this type of fraud is that payroll fraud can continue undetected for a long time. With a median loss of $48,000 per incident, small-business owners have an incentive to examine payroll controls and auditing procedures to prevent payroll fraud schemes. Compare the values on your payroll reports (e.g., Form 941) to your payroll records.

See state specific information page or learn more about workers’ comp exemptions. Required owner inclusion or exclusion forms may need to be signed and given to the insurance company before the effective date. Payroll accuracy is unquestionably one of the most important employer obligations. And even if you use a dependable payroll management system, there’s still payroll audit checklist the possibility of human error. You may make a mistake when entering numbers, forget to include an employee’s pay increase, or forget to delete a terminated worker from your payroll system. Compare what was deducted from your bank to the sums reported in your payroll reports. To make bank reconciliation simpler, consider setting up a dedicated payroll account.

What Is A Payroll Audit?

Certain states have minimum pay frequency laws governing how your pay periods should flow. Gusto takes the stress out of payroll with its bright, intuitive design. Designed with small businesses in mind, Gusto is an excellent payroll software for anyone getting started. Not every payroll error leads to the IRS knocking on your door, but it’s a good idea to bring them up to an accountant to ensure your corrective action doesn’t cause more of a blunder. If you suspect fraud, don’t hesitate to bring in a legal professional to help you navigate your next steps. As you implement new internal controls, you should find it easier to gather the necessary documentation and make fewer errors during the year. Businesses report Federal Unemployment Tax Act tax on Form 940, which is filed annually.

Make sure that the employee and employer are paying the correct amounts towards health insurance and similar expenses. Verify that all of these employees worked for you during the time period. If more workers are listed on your payroll than you had working for you, you may have a problem. Amy terminated an employee, Jenn, in March but forgot to remove Jenn from payroll.

Payroll Walkthroughs

The verification of the recorded accrual can usually be accomplished by comparing it with the amount authorized in the board minutes. The difference between part-time and full-time employees isn’t just the hours they work. Calculate the correct amount of money each employee will receive before withholdings. As you think about these risks, consider the control deficiencies that allow payroll misstatements.

To avoid this situation, we recommend reaching out to these employees a reasonable number of times. If you’re unable to reach them, you need to send their checks to the state as unclaimed funds. Look for the amount of the payment in the GL account, and once you find it, you should be able to see the other side of the transaction. If the other part of the transaction doesn’t show your tax payable account, that would explain why your accounts aren’t clearing. You’ll need to see where the charges are going and make some corrections to your books.

How To Conduct A Payroll Audit For Small Business

She has more than five years of content writing experience and specializes in writing about HR and payroll software for small businesses. Prior to becoming a writer, she worked as an HR Specialist in several multinational companies.

A professional agency such as Accuchex can provide much-needed help with Human Resources needs and questions. This is a critical step and can avoid costly mistakes with fines and fees. Stay updated on the latest products and services anytime anywhere. At Business.org, our research is meant to offer general product and service recommendations. We don’t guarantee that our suggestions will work best for each individual or business, so consider your unique needs when choosing products and services. Break the checklist into three or four smaller lists and do a couple of items every month or two. The more frequent the audit, the less risk of fraud or other issues.

Confirm that mandatory deductions, such as and payroll taxes and wage garnishments, if applicable, are being withheld from employees’ wages. Create a formal payroll audit report to get the information in the same format each time. If the hours paid don’t match the time and attendance report, you can process retroactive pay for the employee and correct the payroll records. IRS and state departments of revenue require businesses to file accurate payroll tax returns and submit taxes withheld from pay. You also need to meet filing and tax deposit requirements for Social Security, Medicare, and unemployment compensation programs.

You should also check if terminated employees are still on the payroll or if there are employee names that you’ve never heard of. The presence of either one indicates that there might be a problem.

You must deduct federal wages, Social Security, and Medicare taxes from your employees paychecks. A detailed reconciliation of the information on the tax forms and the payroll records may be necessary when the auditor believes the tax returns may be incorrectly prepared. Separation of duties is important in the payroll and personnel cycle, especially to prevent overpayments and payments to nonexistent employees. The payroll function should be kept independent of the human resources department, which controls key payroll activities, such as adding and deleting employees. Payroll processing should also be separate from the issuance of payroll disbursements.

What Can Trigger Payroll Audits

Appointment Scheduling 10to8 10to8 is a cloud-based appointment scheduling software that simplifies and automates the process of scheduling, managing, and following up with appointments.

• The same information is also submitted to the Internal Revenue Service and state and local tax commissions when applicable.
• If it’s been a while since you’ve reviewed overtime hours for your state, make sure you’re up-to-date on overtime laws.
• Our free service lets you compare up to 5 price quotes from top-rated payroll providers that match your business needs.
• It may be done by phone, mail, or in person depending on the assigned Auditor.
• To ensure transactions recorded in the University payroll system are supported by appropriate pay-affecting documents.
• It’s also a good idea to look out for any uncashed checks and seek to understand why they are uncashed.
• Make sure you withheld the correct amount of taxes from each employee’s wages including federal income taxes, Social Security, and Medicare taxes.

And the Department of Labor requires an unqualified opinion unless the plan has obtained a limited scope audit exemption from the DOL. Again, payroll audits provide assurance that correct contributions have been made. A payroll audit is different from a financial audit in two major areas.

• A payroll audit can also uncover a fictitious payee, or ghost employee, who does not exist.
• Internal payroll auditing should be conducted regularly to ensure that your payroll records are accurate and properly maintained, and to identify problems before they become issues.
• Some employees commit payroll fraud by adding fake employees to payroll.
• A payroll administrator might have accidentally run payroll twice for one pay period, for instance.
• This makes payroll accounting and payroll auditing easier for you.

It also saves having to do a large audit all at once and means less headache if issues are found. Her work has appeared in “Quarterly,” “Pennsylvania Health & You,” “Constructor” and the “Tribune-Review” newspaper.

An insurance payroll auditor should also ensure that workers are compensated for all hours worked. To reduce payroll costs, many organizations contract with outside organizations to provide staffing. The individuals providing the services are employed by the outside organization. For example, companies frequently contract with information technology services firms to handle the company’s IT management and staffing functions. The fees paid to the outside organization are tested by comparing the amounts with the signed contract arrangement between the company and the outside services firm.